(2027) HEAd …

  • 15-18/06/2027
    Hierarchical assessment of competitive debate in secondary education: efficacy thresholds and demographic invariance
    Marco Costigliolo, Matteo Bozzi, Andrea Fusari, Maurizio Zani
    HEAd, 13th International Conference on Higher Education Advances (Valencia – Spain)
    Atti … (2027) – ISSN 2603-5871

——————–

Abstract:

Structured competitive academic debate fosters critical evaluative thinking, yet longitudinal evidence on instructional dosage and student moderators remains limited. This study analyzes microdata from 1,231 Italian secondary students across 869 adjudicated matches over four consecutive editions (2021–2024) of the Campionato Italiano Giovanile di Debate, scaffolded by the World Schools format and AREL framework.

Using a robust Linear Hierarchical Model accounting for nested clustering, gender, and entry age, we evaluate progression across three ordered achievement tiers. Results reveal significant, stable upward skill migration governed by a longitudinally invariant efficacy threshold of four to five rounds. Furthermore, baseline competence and learning rates are invariant across both gender and age at entry, confirming that adequately dosed, temporally spaced debate may equitably cultivate complex evaluative and argumentative reasoning where traditional secondary curricula often fall short.


Attività